Dealership maintenance schedules a rip off?

Discussion in 'General Motoring' started by Zed, Oct 19, 2007.

  1. Zed

    Zed Guest

    I have an '03 Accent manual trans at 40,000 miles that runs great. I
    have it serviced at Terrible Herbst every 3mos/3,000 miles for oil
    change and fluid fill/check. At 30,000 miles I replaced the spark
    plugs per the owner manual's scheduled maintenance (I keep detailed
    records).

    I decided to have my latest oil change done at a dealership and have
    them also do a multipoint inspection, which showed everything was in
    the green.
    The dealerships have their own maintenance schedule per every x number
    of miles, some of which are extensive and expensive, but not listed in
    the actual owners manual maintenance schedule. I always figured these
    where just a rip off. The service manager put great emphasis on me
    coming back in for my 45,000 mile maintenance package to have this
    that and the other done. I said "sure thing" <wink>. Am I correct to
    avoid them during these dealer scheduled maintenance milestones? Now
    that the car is getting on in miles I want them to do the 3mo./3,000
    routine, but that's all I want them to do, unless something is
    actually wrong. For instance, I got one other oil change + multi point
    inspection done at like 20,000 miles or so, and they decided that the
    (under warranty) battery needed to be replaced (live in very hot
    desert). I figure I've passed up probably an extra $1,000 worth of
    dealership scheduled maintenances done, and the car is, according to
    them, in 100% perfect condition.
     
    Zed, Oct 19, 2007
    #1
  2. Follow the schedule in the Maintenance Log that came with your car and
    you'll be fine. Unless your driving truly falls into the "extreme
    service" category, you're already wasting money by changing your oil
    more frequently than the Hyundai-recommended 7500 mile interval. Special
    dealer service packages that fall outside the factory maintenance
    schedule are designed for one thing, to make the dealer money. Avoid them.
     
    Brian Nystrom, Oct 19, 2007
    #2
  3. I have an '03 Accent manual trans at 40,000 miles that runs great. I
    While the dealership and trained Hyundai techs can fix it much faster
    than guys from other shops, you do pay the premium for that speed. Let
    me put it to you this way, I am going to be replacing a lower
    right-rear control arm on my 02 Sonata. My dealer wants $400 for parts
    and labor to replace it. When I was in a Firestone getting new tires
    put on, I asked how much they charge: $167 parts and labor in total.
    It's a $90 part and takes 30 minutes to install! You do the math.

    When I first had my Sonata, I was so brainwashed that if I didn't have
    the dealer do the maintenance, I was gonna go to Hell or void my
    warranty (or both). Now, the last thing I had done was my timing belt
    but I did buy my own part ($45 versus $125 from the dealership). A lot
    of places don't install parts if you bring them in but the dealer did
    but said "no warranty" if it failed. I was fine with it. Shop around
    for quotes and make sure it's a halfway reputable shop.

    - Thee Chicago Wolf
     
    Thee Chicago Wolf, Oct 20, 2007
    #3
  4. Follow the schedule in the Maintenance Log that came with your car and
    7500? Huh? My manual says 3500 and I do follow that. 7500 doesn't
    sound right.

    - Thee Chicago Wolf
     
    Thee Chicago Wolf, Oct 20, 2007
    #4
  5. It may depend on the particular model, but my Sonata is 7500 miles
    Many cars are 7500 for normal use, 3000 for severe use.

    Severe use Conditions
    A - Repeated short distance driving
    B - Extensive idling
    C - Driving in dusty, rough roads
    D - Driving in areas using salt or other corrosive materials or in very cold
    weather
    E - Driving in sandy areas
    F - More than 50% Driving in heavy city traffic during hot weather above
    90oF (32oC)
    G - Driving in mountainous areas
    H - Driving as a patrol car, taxi, or other commercial use
    I - Driving over 100 MPH (170 KM/H)
     
    Edwin Pawlowski, Oct 20, 2007
    #5
  6. It sounds like you just have a slimeball for a dealer. My local dealer
    sells parts at or below list and their repair prices are comparable to
    the local independent shops.

    BTW, if the timing belt you gave them was an OEM belt, it IS covered
    under warranty, whether they say so or not.
     
    Brian Nystrom, Oct 21, 2007
    #6
  7. You might want to check your manual again (or better yet, the
    Maintenance Log) as AFAIK, every late-model Hyundai has the same 7500
    mile oil change interval. It's also typical of most new cars.
     
    Brian Nystrom, Oct 21, 2007
    #7
  8. You might want to check your manual again (or better yet, the
    I just looked, 3500.

    - Thee Chicago Wolf
     
    Thee Chicago Wolf, Oct 22, 2007
    #8
  9. Zed

    Leonardo Guest

    Service writers at dealerships work for salary 'plus commission'



    L.
     
    Leonardo, Oct 22, 2007
    #9
  10. Zed

    southluke Guest

    My 02 Sonata owner's manua
    and the factory service manual say 7500 miles between oil change
    under "normal" driving conditions.

    But you may be driving that Accent over 100 MPH most of the time s
    3000 miles would be better. Also, please send me your personal dat
    so I can buy a life insurance policy on you

    I have a trusted mechanic that does all my work that I do not want t
    do. He is much cheaper than the dealer and much, much more honest

    The dealer just quoted me around $200 to change the transmissio
    fluid. So I bought $75 worth of that precious Hyundai fluid an
    changed it myself. The instructions are in the service manual. I
    anyone is interested in the procedure, let me know
     
    southluke, Oct 22, 2007
    #10
Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.